ESD may propose increasing Atlantic Yards’ density and offering significantly more subsidy, but it must neither ignore the project’s past commitments, nor risk breaking its future ones

Comments on the Draft Scope of Work for Atlantic Yards Phase II environmental review

On August 24, New York State Empire State Development (ESD) released a Draft Scope of Work (DSOW) for a Second Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SSEIS) in support of a revised project plan put forth by the development team of Cirrus Workforce Housing and LCOR.

BrooklynSpeaks is concerned the DSOW attempts to bury important elements of Atlantic Yards history by defining the “Proposed Project” solely as the plan’s remaining undeveloped building lots. In so doing, ESD avoids accountability not only for unfulfilled project commitments like affordable housing, but also for environmental impacts (such as from arena traffic) that have been documented over Atlantic Yards’ two-decade history. We call on ESD to make a full account of major environmental impacts, mitigation measures and material public benefits identified in prior environmental impact statements. This accounting should include, at minimum, major transportation and pedestrian mitigation, open-space commitments, affordable housing, community facilities, construction mitigation, and other commitments embodied in the continuing Memorandum of Environmental Commitments. The accounting must be based upon actual project operating experience and the SSEIS must identify new solutions where previously specified mitigations have been insufficient.

Atlantic Yards was approved under the UDC Act as a “land use improvement project,” for the purpose of eliminating blight. The SSEIS must assess the current factual basis for this purpose given the redevelopment of most of the property cited as exhibiting blight in 2006. Although ESD is expanding the project’s purposes to include addressing a “statewide housing crisis” as stated in the DSOW, the proposed affordable housing program will result in less low- and very low-income housing than envisioned under past SEQRA approvals. Alternatives studied under the SSEIS must therefore include a restoration of the income bands for affordable apartments cited in those approvals.

Additional project entitlements that increase residential density by 37% are substantially front-loaded into the first two project buildings, and none extend to the eastern rail yard block 1121 where the largest share of Atlantic Yards open space is proposed. Nor has ESD yet identified a source of funding for the platform on block 1121. That raises a significant concern that open space will either be delayed or not completed. The SSEIS must include an alternative study that avoids this outcome by completing block 1121 first.

Finally, because public contribution to the modified plan is proposed to increase dramatically, the SSEIS should clearly distinguish among three rationales that may support elements of the Proposed Project: eliminating the remaining physical rail yard condition and completing the original land-use-improvement purpose; providing sufficient development value to finance expensive platform construction; and pursuing current State housing-production objectives. It should explain the relationship among the remaining physical conditions, platform cost, State and other public assistance, proposed development density, affordable-housing requirements, and current housing-production objectives. That transparency will also improve the alternatives analysis by allowing ESD and the public to understand which objectives are fixed and which assumptions are capable of adjustment.

Download BrooklynSpeaks' full comments on the DSOW.